 |

Review: The Sonos Digital Music System
by
Dan Hanttula
 |
"...If you need to read the
manual to use this system, you're an idiot."
|
Several years ago, I spent
an entire week wiring my home with audio cables and Ethernet. The
project included an automated switch to change the room where music was
being played by simply touching a wall switch mounted near the speakers.
In the end, I had a simple system that performed as well as the
expensive commercial solutions that were on the market at the time.
LOVE AT FIRST SIGHT: THE SONOS SYSTEM
Today, Santa Barbara,
California based Sonos Incorporated
has developed a modular music network that makes anyone's current music setup
look like an 8-track stereo. The Sonos Digital Music System is, to put
it simply, a receiver that you can plug into any power outlet and a pair
of speakers to play digital music from all the computers in your home
network. If it sounds easy, you're right. The system is
designed so that anyone can put it together without any technical
knowledge of computers or home networking.
Right out of the box,
the Quick Setup poster includes a 3-step process that will actually
take longer to read, than it will to accomplish. Granted, the poster
includes information on installations with firewalls and for
non-standard Operating Systems, but the process is so streamlined
that it takes just minutes to get up and running. The very first ZonePlayer must be connected to your network using an Ethernet cable
(included), and subsequent units will automatically connect to the
first ZonePlayer via Sonosnet, the company's proprietary wireless networking
system.
 |
|
The Sonos ZonePlayer is the heart of the
Digital Music System. Simply place one of these in each location
you would like to have music, plug them into an outlet and add
speakers. |
The Sonos Desktop
Controller, a software application for your computer, lets you set up the music to
be streamed to your players and create and manage playlists. You can
also use the software to control the music being played through each ZonePlayer, but that's
a feature best saved for the Sonos Remote Control unit.
THE SIGHTS & SOUNDS OF MUSIC
Once the ZonePlayers and music shares are set up, the real fun
begins. The Sonos Remote Control features a full-color screen that
displays zones and music. Zones are a friendly name for the Sonos
systems you set up in each room. For example, the "Bedroom" zone would
be a ZonePlayer plugged in and attached to speakers in your master
bedroom. When you access each zone, you can control the volume and
the playlist for that specific location or link them with other
zones to synchronize the music being played and manage whole-house
volume with one touch.
As the music plays, the remote displays the
current song, along with the artist name, album art and title (see
screenshot, below). An orange graphical progress bar provides a
visual indication of the current song's progress and the remote
makes the best use of the screen size by adding the upcoming song
title and the number of songs in the queue to the display.
Our only complaint with the wireless remote
is the price. The stand-alone remote control retails for $399. This
makes it more expensive than but all but the top-of-the-line
universal remotes. As such, we expect it to manage all the devices
in a room. This is especially important when you connect component
stereo units to the ZonePlayer (see 2nd paragraph of AN
AUDIOPHILE'S EYE, below) Or, as an alternate solution, Sonos should
make a miniature "iPod Shuffle" style remote with only the necessary
features for placement in each zone. This would allow you to manage
the entire system with the color screen, and access the individual
zones in the room you're currently in with a tiny panel. Instead,
each Sonos ZonePlayer has volume up/down and a mute button, which is
not enough functionality for our taste and would be absolutely useless if
the unit is hidden away.
 |
|
The Now Playing screen
on the
remote control
includes vital information like the current music title and next
song in queue, as well as flashy features like album cover
graphics and a status bar to indicate how far you are through the
current song. |
AN AUDIOPHILE'S EYE
The system supports
unlocked digital music, including compressed MP3, WMA, AAC (MPEG4),
Ogg Vorbis, Flac (lossless), WAV and AIFF files. Music locked by DRM
encryption (like Apple iTunes or Windows Media Audio Lossless)
formats are not currently supported and -from what we can tell-
never will be due to each company's strict copyright strategies. The Sonos Digital Music System can
manage up to 30,000 songs from as many as 16 music shares (which may
exist on separate computers or Network Attached Storage drives).In addition to
user-ripped music, the Sonos Digital Music System also supports
Internet radio (via streaming MP3) and Rhapsody 3.0.
A TECHNOPHILE'S EYE
The Sonos Music
System also has some unexpected features for true home automation
buffs. On the back of every ZonePlayer is a subwoofer output port,
four spring binding posts for speaker connections, and four RCA
jacks for input/output to a stereo, home theatre or even an iPod.
Any device connected via the RCA input can automatically be streamed
anywhere else in the house. Last but not least, four Ethernet ports
on the back of the system also allow you to plug in a laptop in any
room and connect to the network (albeit at a speed slower than WiFi).
Although the Sonos Digital Music System does
what it promises flawlessly, a few high end features would have been
greatly appreciated by our review team. The
desktop software should have an "audio preview" feature to listen to
the music through the PC speakers while you're creating playlists,
since it is entirely possible to create a playlist in a room without
a Sonos ZonePlayer. In addition, the desktop software will skip a
song if you move it from the MP3 folder where it was residing when
you created your playlist. A "find" feature should be added to
relocate the music. Although the unit's usability is
absolutely unmatched, an indicator or test system to display when
the speakers are out of phase (when the red wire and black wire are
incorrectly reversed) would have been helpful, especially when you
are creating a "server room" of Sonos ZonePlayers that tether to
whole house audio wiring. Finally, with all of the gee-whiz features
already built-in to the Sonos Digital Music System, a "follow me"
feature that automatically played music when you walked near a
ZonePlayer with the remote would have made this the ultimate
accessory for the digerati elite.
Speaking of the
remote, when plugged in to a power outlet, it should have a screen
saver showing atomic-clock synchronized time. A clock feature would
also permit a timed "sleep" function that will allow music to turn
off after a preset delay and an alarm to wake up to music. These are
no-brainer additions that should be a component of any home
automation music system.
One critical feature
that was added during our review process was music volume averaging. As accomplished music
scavengers will attest, every now and then one song may play at a
significantly higher volume than the rest of your collection. This is especially
the case when you have music recorded from different sources, made "home
hits" where you have created MP3s of your own band, or a live
recording from a concert. In these instances, a music volume
averaging feature that keeps the sound of the music at
the same level is critical. And, much to the delight of our review
team, the feature was added during an auto-update (v1.2) in
mid-July.
 |
|
| |
|
 |
Pros:
The definitive whole-house audio system. Unbelievable
power behind the easiest installation procedure ever created by man. |
Cons:
High cost for
whole-house implementation and additional remote control units. Could
offer high-end music control features. No DRM (Digital Rights
Management) support. |
|
| |
|
SUMMARY
Users that have
already digitized their entire collection will find this product is
their dream come true. The Sonos Digital Music System will quickly and
easily allow you to "mobilize" your audio collection throughout your
entire home and, with the impressive product design, if you need to read the
manual to use this system, you're an idiot. So beginners looking to
quickly employ an advanced audio system will find equal pleasure in
the ease of installation and use. Although our editors wanted more
high-end features, these are probably just our personal pet peeves,
and as long as you can afford the initial expenditure to acquire the
system, you will be delighted with the performance and
features. Best of all, users can grow the system as their needs
increase, and move the units around (or even transport it to a new
home), making this system superior to
"installed" high-end home audio solutions.
Sonos is currently
available in North America and Europe, with a German language
version currently nearing release. The company is currently working
on a table-top/wall mountable charging cradle for the remote which
should be available before Christmas. Sonos plans to expand to a
larger market in 2006. The company also plans to "fill out the
product line" with additional products they will be announcing at
CES in January 2006.
PURCHASE:
|